10 Best Hunting Arrow Reviews (Carbon, Fiberglass, and More)

Best Hunting Arrow

Even with today's most advanced firearms, nothing beats the joy of hunting game with a bow and arrow.

Bow hunting has come a long way and has seen plenty of advancements over the years. The wooden arrow has been superseded today by aluminum and carbon fiber arrows, with new technologies making the arrows better, more accurate, and deadlier to shoot.

This review of the best hunting arrows presents you with the best arrows for your hunting rig, including those with the newest technologies. It also presents you with all the extra information that you'll need to make the right choice.

Product Name

Length

Diameter

Material

Rating

Current Price

1. Carbon Express Maxima

32.5 in

0.295 in

Carbon

4.8

2. Misayar Arrows

30 in

0.307 in

Carbon

4.2

3. Gold Tip Hunter XT

32 in

0.300 in

Carbon

4.3

4. Huntingdoor Wooden

31 in

0.312 in

Wood

4.0

5. Antsir Hunting Arrow

30 in

0.314 in

Fiberglass

3.5

6. M.A.K Hunting Arrows

30 in

0.309 in

Carbon

3.9

7. Huntingdoor 31-Inch

31 in

0.295 in

Carbon

4.2

8. Archery Sharly Feathers

31 in

0.299 in

Carbon

3.7

9. Gold Tip Hunter Arrows

32 in

0.30 in

Carbon

5.0

10. Beman ICS Hunter

32 in

N/A

Carbon

5.0

1. Carbon Express 12-Pack  Maxima Hunter Arrow

Editor's Rating: (4.8 / 5)

Carbon Express 12-Pack Maxima Hunter Arrow
  • Diameter: 0.295 inch
  • Length: 32.5 inches
  • Weight: 8-9.7 GPI
  • Material: Carbon

Developed with perfection in mind, this Carbon Express set combines all the available technologies to offer you the best possible hunting arrows for the money.

The package is available as a 6 or 12 pack, with each arrow in the set having a maximum weight deviation of +/-1.0 grains and a straightness tolerance of +/-0.0025. There are also 3 spine ratings available.

You get a high-quality and 32.5-inch long carbon fiber shaft. Each one got made using Carbon Express' BuffTuff weaving technology to get a good spine consistency, durability and arrow strength.

The finish also includes the Mossy Oak Treestand camouflage pattern to offer you the best hunting arrow that is both reliable and beautiful.

Pros:

  • Built to offer maximum accuracy & strength
  • High-quality arrows with a straightness tolerance of +/-0.0025-inch
  • Available as a set of 6 or 12 arrows
  • BuffTuff technology provides a consistent spine and strength
  • Available in 3 spine ratings

Cons:

  • This Maxima Hunter set of arrows is costly
  • List Element

2. Misayar 30-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows

Editor's Rating: (4.2 / 5)

Misayar 30-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows
  • Diameter: 0.307 inch
  • Length: 30 inches
  • Weight: 12 GPI
  • Material: Carbon

For those who want top hunting arrows but at a budget price, why not check out this pack of 12 arrows from Misayar. They are very thin at just 0.307 inch, making them a very nice set for hunting.

With these Misayar's arrows, you get a weight of 12 GPI, which will help to penetrate the hide and flesh of most game animals. Its composite carbon shaft also provides stability and durability.

The vanes are made of plastic and are very colorful, while the field points are made from hardened steel to provide a long service life. You can always change it out though and add a 100-grain broadhead tip.

Pros:

  • High-quality carbon arrows with a 0.307-inch outer diameter
  • 12 arrows offered at an attractive price
  • Colorful vanes make it easy to keep an eye on the arrows
  • 12 Grains Per Inch offers a good arrow weight for good penetration
  • Matched with 100-grain broadheads

Cons:

  • These arrows are great at 55 lbs of bow draw weight, but not higher

3. Gold Tip Hunter XT 12-Pack Hunter Arrows

Editor's Rating: (4.3 / 5)

Gold Tip Hunter XT 12-Pack Hunter Arrows
  • Diameter: 0.300 inch
  • Length: 32 inches
  • Weight: 8.9 GPI
  • Material: Carbon

Gold Tip's Hunter XT is a premium quality hunting arrow, designed for those who appreciate high performance at a fair price. It comes with a black shaft, including 2-inch green and white raptor vanes.

There are 4 different spine ratings available and these start from 300 to 340, 400, and 500. With a factory length of 32 inches and an 8.9 grains per inch weight, this arrow also features a slim 0.300-inch outer diameter, which is ideal for hunting.

Included components in the package are a GT nock and accu-lite inserts for screwing in the tips.

The hunter XT is a well crafted mid-weight arrow, balancing speed and deep penetration to produce a hunting arrow that you can depend on for years to come.

Pros:

  • Straightness tolerance is +/-0.003 inch
  • Each arrow in the set has a +/-2 gr weight tolerance
  • Available in 4 spine ratings
  • Features raptor 2-inch vanes for super accurate flights

Cons:

  • The price is a bit high

4. Huntingdoor Turkey Feather 12-Pack Wooden Arrows

Editor's Rating: (4 / 5)

Huntingdoor Turkey Feather 12-Pack Wooden Arrows
  • Diameter: 0.312 inch
  • Length: 31 inches
  • Weight: 35 grams per arrow
  • Material: Wood

If you are a passionate archer who loves recurve or longbows deeply, then why not spice things up with a truly old-school arrow?

Huntingdoor presents this classically beautiful piece of art, handmade from natural wood, fletched with 5-inch long turkey feathers, and ready to shoot straight out of the box.

This set has 12 arrows, each 31 inches long with a 0.312-inch diameter. They're rated for low-weight 40 - 60 lbs recurve or longbows, and they come already nocked and with a 100-grain field point.

You should note that while these arrows look amazing, they're neither as straight, accurate, nor as durable as carbon fiber arrows.

Pros:

  • Very beautiful bows ideal for traditional archers
  • Affordable price
  • Comes fully assembled and ready to shoot
  • Lovely turkey-feather fletching

Cons:

  • The arrows are not very uniform
  • They can break more easily than aluminum and carbon arrows

5. Antsir 12-Pack Fiberglass Hunting Arrows

Editor's Rating: (3.5 / 5)

Antsir 12-Pack Fiberglass Hunting Arrows
  • Diameter: 0.314 inch
  • Length: 30 inches
  • Weight: 125 grains
  • Material: Fiberglass

You can get your hunting arrows for a lot less than the price of carbon arrows if you're willing to indulge fiberglass. Usually provided for beginners, fiberglass arrows do have their advantages, including a low price and durability.

This set comes with 12 arrows, each featuring brightly-colored plastic vanes and a nock, plus an insert to host the nickel-plated stainless steel field points.

Made for 30 - 60 lbs bows, and featuring a 0.314-inch diameter, each arrow has a spine rating of 500, plus a length of 30 inches, which is neither too soft, nor too rigid.

Fiberglass arrows are okay and often accurate to a given level, but you shouldn't expect the strength and precision of a carbon arrow from a fiberglass arrow.

Pros:

  • 12 pcs of fiberglass arrows at a great price
  • Ideal for beginners
  • Adjustable nocks to create a perfect fit for the bow
  • Nickel-plated stainless steel field points included

Cons:

  • They are not very accurate but they are affordable
  • Not ideal for expert archers

6. M.A.K 30-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows

Editor's Rating: (3.9 / 5)

M.A.K 30-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows
  • Diameter: 0.309 inch
  • Length: 30 inches
  • Weight: N/A
  • Material: Carbon

M.A.K's carbon hunting arrows offer you a great opportunity of buying well-made carbon arrows at a great price. The arrows are 0.309-inch wide and 30 inches long, and are recommended for 40 - 60 pound bows.

In addition to the well-made shaft, the arrows also come with nickel-plated stainless steel field tips and nicely-colored plastic fletching for improved accuracy.

As an added bonus, you'll receive 6 vanes, 6 nocks and 3 chisel-tipped broadheads for hunting, all for free. Its spine rating is 500 and its price is very attractive, making this one of the best hunting arrows for the money.

Pros:

  • A high-quality dozen of carbon arrows at an attractive price
  • Includes free replacement nocks, fletching, and broadheads
  • Adjustable nocks allow better shots
  • Offered at a nice price

Cons:

  • N/A

7. Huntingdoor 31-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows

Editor's Rating: (4.2 / 5)

Huntingdoor 31-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows
  • Diameter: 0.297 inch
  • Length: 31 inches
  • Weight: N/A
  • Material: Carbon

Huntingdoor is making an offer here that few can resist. You get a full package containing 6 carbon arrows with field tips, plus 6 3-bladed broadheads for hunting.

The field tips can get changed easily and the broadheads are high quality and durable tips that'll penetrate deep into any game and cause enough damage.

You get a carbon shaft with a 0.297-inch diameter, adjustable nocks to make the arrow fit your bow perfectly, colored plastic vanes for easy identification, and standard thread inserts for switching between the field tips and broadheads.

It has a 500 spine rating and a recommendation for bows with a 40-55 lb draw weight. The arrows are also fully assembled and ready for shooting, straight out of the box.

Pros:

  • Comes with 6 field tips and 6 3-blade broadheads
  • Features high-strength and durable carbon shaft
  • Ideal for bows with 40 - 55 pounds draw weight
  • Comes fully fletched, nocked, and ready to shoot

Cons:

  • Only 6 arrows unlike comparable packages with 12 arrows

8. Archery Sharly 31-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows

Editor's Rating: (3.7 / 5)

Archery Sharly 31-Inch Carbon Hunting Arrows
  • Diameter: 0.299 inch
  • Length: 31 inches
  • Weight: N/A
  • Material: Carbon

Featuring natural feather fletching, these arrows are perfect for traditional archers who like to keep things old school. There are 2 red and 1 black 4.5-inch long feathers on each arrow.

Made from carbon fiber, each shaft is straight and accurate, providing you with better hits and longer lasting arrows. They also have a very thin outer diameter of 0.299 inch, making them less susceptible to wind drag during flight.

One of the advantages of this arrow set is that you can choose either a 6-pack or a 12-pack. The arrows have a 500 spine rating and a recommendation for draw weights up to 50 lbs.

Its tips are removable and can get replaced with 100-grain broadheads. The nocks, however, are glued tight, making it impossible to make any adjustments to the arrow before shooting.

Pros:

  • Available in 6 or 12 pack
  • 4.5 inches long natural feather fletching
  • Made from carbon for strength and durability
  • Very beautiful arrows, great for traditional archers

Cons:

  • Nocks are glued and cannot be adjusted

9. Gold Tip Hunter XT Camo Arrow Shafts

Editor's Rating: (5 / 5)

Gold Tip Hunter XT Camo Arrow Shafts
  • Diameter: 0.302 inch
  • Length: 32 inches
  • Weight: 9.3 GPI
  • Material: Carbon

Gold Tip's Hunter XT arrows are well known for their precision, but you don't need to buy the entire arrow package, because you can just buy only the shafts, which is the offer here.

Although the price might seem high for just the shafts, you should note that these are very high-end shafts, with a straightness tolerance of +/-0.003 and a weight tolerance of +/- 2 grains.

In addition to that, each shaft is also covered in a Realtree Xtra camo finish for that true hunting feel.

Of course, this package is for the hunter who knows what he's doing, wants to customize his arrows by himself, and needs the very best arrow shafts he can get.

Pros:

  • Available in 3 spine options
  • The perfect carbon shaft for expert hunters
  • high precision straightness tolerance of +/-0.003 inch
  • Weight tolerance of +/-2 grains
  • Includes a GT Nock

Cons:

  • The package comes without fletching and arrowhead
  • Price is high but the quality is worth it

10. Beman ICS 6-Pack Classic Hunter Arrows

Editor's Rating: (5 / 5)

Beman ICS 6-Pack Classic Hunter Arrows
  • Diameter: N/A
  • Length: 32 inches
  • Weight: 7.3 - 9.5 GPI
  • Material: Carbon

The ICS Hunter Classic from Beman is a popular and well-made arrow, tested and relied on by lots of expert archers. This offer is for the arrow without a head.

It comes with inserts for either installing practice field tips or for broadheads. You also get vanes on the arrow and a direct-fit S nock.

There are 3 spine options available and they include a 300 spine with 9.5 GPI weight, a 340 spine with 9.3 GPI, a 400 with 8.4, and a 500 spine with a 7.3 GPI weight rating.

Each arrow also has a straightness tolerance of +/-0.003, and they come a few inches longer, so you can cut them to the right length for your rig. The Beman ICS Classic is not just a good hunting arrow, it's one of the best carbon hunting arrows available.

Pros:

  • Arrows available in 4 different spine ratings
  • Package includes 6 high-quality arrows at an attractive price
  • Includes direct-fit S nocks and CB inserts
  • Backed by a Beman 1-year warranty

Cons:

  • N/A

How to Buy the Best Hunting Arrows

How to Buy the Best Hunting Arrows

There are many factors to generally look out for when choosing an arrow. These include the length, material, arrow spine, and weight.

When it comes to hunting arrows, good penetration becomes more important and this gets created by combining more weight, a thinner shaft, and good speed.

Following is a closer look at these factors, and how they can combine to create the ideal hunting arrow.

#1. Arrow Weight

Truly, a heavier arrow will not fly as fast as a lighter arrow, but it often penetrates the animal deeper. As an arrow gets fired from a bow, it travels with a momentum which is a result of the bow's draw weight in pounds and the arrows weight in grains.

The environment will have more impact on a lighter arrow fired with the same force and it will not hit the game with as much impact as the heavier arrow.

Heavier arrows also cut down on the noise made by the bow when firing the arrow. For hunting, therefore, a heavier arrow is always preferred.

#2. Arrow Length

The length of your arrows will depend on your bow's draw length. So, you need to measure your draw length first, before knowing what bow length to buy. The ideal arrow length is usually 0.5 or 1 inch longer than your draw length.

You can either measure your bow's draw length in an archery shop or draw the bow by yourself and have a friend measure the distance to the back of the riser. You can alternatively measure your arm-span, spread out horizontally, and divide it by 2.5.

#3. Shaft Thickness

The thickness of the arrow shaft is another important factor in determining how suitable an arrow is for hunting. An ideal hunting arrow should be as thin as possible, allowing it to fly with less wind drift.

Its walls should also be thicker than that of comparable target-practice arrows because this makes it heavier. This thickness is the difference between the shaft's outer and inner diameters, for hollow shafts like aluminum and carbon fiber.

#4. Straightness

The straightness of the arrow is another marker for quality. Each manufacturer provides a tolerance figure that got used in measuring and maintaining the arrow's straightness.

You'll get fraction numbers with 3 decimal places between 0.001 and 0.006. The higher numbers are less straight, while the lower numbers are higher quality, straight arrow shafts.

#5. Arrow Spine

Arrow spine combines many features like the material, length and weight of the arrow shaft to find how much or how little it wiggles in flight.

In other words, it's a measure of arrow stiffness, with lower numbers like 300 being stiffer than the more flexible arrows with a higher spine rating like 500.

#6. Arrow Type/Shaft Material

Arrows are usually classified according to the materials they got produced from. Wood was originally used in arrow making, but technological advancements have introduced aluminum, fiberglass, and carbon arrows.

Fiberglass is great for kids and beginners, aluminum is affordable and good for practicing, while carbon fiber arrows are the best for hunting.

Carbon arrows are flexible and very durable. Due to the strength of carbon fiber, the shafts can also be made thinner to cut down on wind drag, and their density gives them the perfect weight for optimal penetration of your target.

#7. Fletching

Arrow fletching was traditionally accomplished using feathers, but most arrows today come with plastic vanes. Still, a feather remains the best fletching material.

Although there are often exceptions, conventional vanes are usually 2, 3, or 4 inches long, with the longer ones stabilizing broadheads better, while the shorter ones are more forgiving in windy situations.

You'll find 3 types of fletching turns. There's the straight one with vanes that are parallel to the arrow shaft, a helical fletching turn, which is the best broadhead stabilizer, and an offset turn which combines the two.

Helical fletching turns are the most accurate for hunting with broadheads, but only if your bow doesn't use a containment arrow rest. Else, the offset fletching turn works with most arrow rests and is also the most popular choice among hunters.

Conclusion

We have reached the end of this best hunting arrows review and you should hopefully have found what you're looking for. As each archer or hunter is different, so too are personal choices, including the choice of an arrow.

As it stands, you are free to choose between a high-quality carbon hunting arrow and a good hunting arrow for the money.

Your needs, skill level, personal preference, and budget, will combine to help you make the right choice.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: