10 Best Broadheads: Fixed Blade, Mechanical, Hybrid and More

Best Broadhead

You can practice with a field tip arrow for as long as you want, but when it's time to hunt real game, you'll need a broadhead. With the different types of broadheads available, folks often want to know which one is the best.

The truth is, it all depends. Your best choice will depend on the kind of game you're hunting, as well as your personal bow preferences.

Following is a review of the best broadheads, including all the information you'll need to choose the right broadhead tips for your hunting gear.

Product Name

Grain weight

Diameter

Blades

Package

Rating

Current Price

1. Huntingdoor Broadhead Arrow Tips

125

1 in

3

12 pcs

4.2

2. Savage Village Broadhead Hunting Arrow Tips

100

1.12 in

3

5 pcs

4.2

3. G5 Outdoors Stainless Steel Montec Broadheads

85/100/125

1.12 in

3

3 pcs

4.6

4. Rage Xtreme Mechanical Broadhead

100

2.3 in

2

3 pcs

4.2

5. Carbon Express XT Crossbow Broadheads

100/125

1.18 in

2

3 pcs

4.3

6. Muzzy Mx-3 Trocar Tip Bow-Hunting Broadheads

75/100/125

1.25 in

3

3 pcs

4.0

7. OTW Hunting Stainless Steel Broadheads

100

1.25 in

3

6 pcs

4.1

8. Supercaptain Hybrid Broadheads

100

1 in

4

5 pcs

4.8

9. Muzzy Phantom 4-Blade Broadheads

100/125

1.125 in

4

3 pcs

4.4

10. FlyArchery Traditional Arrow Broadheads

100

0.6 in

N/A

12 pcs

5.0

1. Huntingdoor 125-Grain 3-Blade 12-Pack Broadhead Arrow Tips

Editor's Rating: 4.2 out of 5 stars (4.2 / 5)

Huntingdoor 125-Grain 3-Blade 12-Pack Broadhead Arrow Tips
  • Grain weight: 125 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1.035 inches
  • Type of Blade: Fixed

Huntingdoor presents a package here which is great for any hunter that needs a pack of affordable broadheads. The quality might not be top grade, but you do get some value here.

Firstly, the price is nice for a pack of 12 broadheads. Secondly, they are heavy-duty 125-grain tips, designed to take down nearly all sizes of game. And thirdly, they are very sharp, guaranteeing a clean kill each time.

Their fixed design makes them rugged broadheads which deeply slices and penetrates any animal, while the 3-blade style makes sure that enough damage gets done to leave a good blood trail when necessary.

These tips are designed for crossbow bolts and compound bow arrows alike. They are also easy to install and can get sharpened to razor-sharpness if there's the need.

Pros:

  • Heavy-duty 3 strong and sharp fixed blades
  • Best crossbow broadheads for deer hunting
  • Easy to install and use
  • Swept wing blades improve flight
  • Great price for a package of 12 broadheads

Cons:

  • Not made from the most durable materials

2. Savage Village 100-Grain Broadhead Hunting Arrow Tips

Editor's Rating: 4.2 out of 5 stars (4.2 / 5)

Savage Village 100-Grain Broadhead Hunting Arrow Tips
  • Grain weight: 100 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1.12 inches
  • Type of Blade: Fixed

Made from a one-piece stainless steel cast, this broadhead is a very rugged arrow tip. It will penetrate deep into any animal and cause enough damage for a quick kill.

This broadhead has a 1.12-inch diameter, plus 3 blades to make sure you cut muscles against the grain. The stainless steel material is very strong and durable, being able to withstand multiple uses without problems. The blades can also get re-sharpened without issues.

You can take down hogs, zebras, bears, and of course deer and elks with this broadhead. It's a near-exact copy of another top-rated broadhead which is very popular and flies like a field-tip.

Pros:

  • Made from stainless steel for maximum durability
  • One-piece fixed blade design for super strength
  • 3-blade design for efficient kills
  • Spin-tested to avoid wobbling in flight
  • Backed by a 30-day money-back guarantee

Cons:

  • It's delivered dull and needs sharpening

3. G5 Outdoors 100% Stainless Steel Montec Broadheads

Editor's Rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars (4.6 / 5)

G5 Outdoors 100% Stainless Steel Montec Broadheads
  • Grain weight: 85/100/125 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1.12 inches
  • Type of Blade: Fixed blade

Designed to fit most standard arrows, the G5 Montec is a very popular broadhead developed and manufactured by G5 Outdoors, a family-owned business dedicated to the outdoors and to hunting, especially.

It's a one-piece metal made from injection molding and featuring 100% stainless steel for extreme strength and long life. This is the ultimate fixed-blade broadhead and you can get it in 3 different grain weights of 85, 100, and 125 grains to fit your needs.

There are 3 broadheads per pack, each with a maximum diameter of 1.12 inches. The Montec broadhead is spin tested, strength tested and confirmed extremely sharp for quick kills.

If you use a crossbow, then G5 Outdoors also has high-speed versions with 100 and 125-grain weights available.

Pros:

  • Made from 100% steel for superior strength
  • Cut-On-Contact design allows effective use with low-powered bows
  • Available in 85, 100, and 125 grains
  • Crossbow model also available
  • Spin tested for smooth flights

Cons:

  • The G5 Montec is a relatively expensive broadhead

4. Rage Xtreme Mechanical 100-Grain Broadhead

Editor's Rating: 4.2 out of 5 stars (4.2 / 5)

Rage Xtreme Mechanical 100-Grain Broadhead
  • Grain weight: 100 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 2.3 inches
  • Type of Blade: Mechanical blades

Rage is known for its high-tech mechanical broadheads, featuring distinctive designs and plenty of destructive power. Rage broadheads are also known for their accuracy and razor-sharp blades.

This particular Rage Xtreme comes with a 2.3-inch cutting diameter, made from razor-sharp 0.035 inch stainless steel blades. It also features an improved shock collar to ensure proper retention of the blades and to only open up when necessary.

Rage makes this broadhead in 100-grain weight and offers a chisel-tipped version, as well as a high-speed crossbow version.

If you want a mechanical broadhead with good technology, then this Rage Xtreme is definitely worth a closer look. The only disadvantage is its slightly high price for a pack of three broadheads.

Pros:

  • Features a 2.3-inch cutting diameter for perfect blood trails
  • Also available with a chisel-tip and for crossbows
  • Razor sharp blades for almost effortless cutting
  • Highly accurate tips
  • The best mechanical broadheads for crossbow hunting

Cons:

  • The Rage Xtreme costs more than most other broadheads

5. Carbon Express XT 3-Pack Crossbow Broadheads

Editor's Rating: 4.3 out of 5 stars (4.3 / 5)

Carbon Express XT 3-Pack Crossbow Broadheads
  • Grain weight: 100/125 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1.12
  • Type of Blade: Fixed

The Carbon Express XT features 2 blades but 6 cutting edges, making it one of the best broadheads for crossbows. This is because it creates up to 250% larger wounds than comparable tips.

In addition to that, the blades get made from stainless steel, although the ferrule is made from aircraft-grade aluminum. This broadhead has the high accuracy of a field point and is available in either 100 or 125-grain weights.

To further increase its killing power, its stainless steel blades are additionally serrated, guaranteeing a better blood trail and a faster kill.

Each package includes 3 broadheads and this means it's not cheap. But its maximum damage delivery, quality materials, precision, and aerodynamic profile, really combine to make the Carbon Express XT broadhead worth every penny for crossbow shooters.

Pros:

  • Maximum damage from 6 cutting edges
  • Available in 100 and 125-grain versions
  • The best crossbow broadhead
  • Accurate like a field point
  • Serrated blades for more cutting power

Cons:

  • It's not cheap
  • The cutting diameter could be wider

6. Muzzy Mx-3 Trocar Tip 3-Blade Bow-Hunting Broadheads

Editor's Rating: 4 out of 5 stars (4 / 5)

Muzzy Mx-3 Trocar Tip 3-Blade Bow-Hunting Broadheads
  • Grain weight: 75/100/125 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1.25 inches
  • Type of Blade: Chisel tip fixed blades

Muzzy's Mx-3 is designed to penetrate deeply and crush bones, while also tearing flesh apart. There are 3 weights available, 75, 100, and 125 grains. Each features 0.025-inch thick stainless steel blades with 1.25 inches of cutting diameter.

For the 75 and 100-grain broadheads, you get an aircraft-grade grade aluminum ferrule, while the 125-grain version features a stainless steel ferrule.

The blades have a decreased surface area to cut down on disturbances in flight and produce a higher accuracy, while the Trocar tip guarantees bone splitting.

You get a pack of 3 broadheads, each having 3 fixed blades, a bone-crushing tip and a high accuracy that make them great broadheads for deer and other large game hunting.

Pros:

  • Comes with a bone-crushing Trocar tip
  • Available in 3 weights of 75, 100, 125 grains
  • Features interlocking blades
  • High-grade ferrule and 0.025-inch stainless steel blades

Cons:

  • Cutting diameter could be wider

7. OTW Hunting 6-Pack Stainless Steel Broadheads

Editor's Rating: 4.1 out of 5 stars (4.1 / 5)

OTW Hunting 6-Pack Stainless Steel Broadheads
  • Grain weight: 100 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1.25 inches
  • Type of Blade: Removable blade

How about a great broadhead package at a great price? This OTW hunting package comes with 6 broadhead tips for your arrows and includes a portable box for safely storing and transporting them.

The broadheads are pre-sharpened and super sharp, and they are available in 2 variants. Both variants feature fixed blades, with one including a chisel-tip for some bone-crushing action.

You get a 100-grain weight, 3 super-sharp, and replaceable blades on each broadhead, plus a 6-month warranty coverage, all at a great budget price.

Pros:

  • 6 stainless steel broadheads at a great price
  • Comes in a portable carrying box
  • Available with a chisel-tip
  • Includes a 6-month warranty

Cons:

  • N/A

8. Supercaptain Hybrid 100-Grain Broadheads

Editor's Rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars (4.8 / 5)

Supercaptain Hybrid 100-Grain Broadheads
  • Grain weight: 100 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1 inch
  • Type of Blade: Hybrid

Hybrid broadheads are in a class of their own. This one combines the advantages of fixed and mechanical blades to offer you a powerful broadhead that is really worth its price. You get 2 fixed blades and 2 expandable ones on each tip.

The blades get produced from stainless steel, while the ferrules come from carbon steel, providing you with maximum strength for all hunting situations. These tips have a 100-grain weight and are additionally silver-colored.

You get the 5 broadheads carefully packaged in a box, all lightweight and extremely sharp at a low-budget price. This is also a great broadhead for either target practicing or for hunting small game.

The manufacturer promises that if you're not impressed by the quality and accuracy of these tips, you'll still have a 30-day money-back guarantee to fall back on.

Pros:

  • High-precision hybrid broadheads
  • Carbon steel ferrules and stainless steel blades
  • Features 2 fixed and 2 expandable blades
  • Can be used with crossbows, recurve and compound bows
  • 30-day money-back guarantee

Cons:

  • N/A

9. Muzzy Phantom 4-Blade Broadheads

Editor's Rating: 4.4 out of 5 stars (4.4 / 5)

Muzzy Phantom 4-Blade Broadheads
  • Grain weight: 100/125 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 1.125 inches
  • Type of Blade: Fixed

Muzzy Phantom broadheads are designed to easily slice through flesh, crush any bones in their way, and leave a nice blood trail based on their 4-blade and solid stainless-steel design.

They also offer the level of precision of field points, making them truly excellent broadheads.

The 4 blades get arranged into 2 groups, with the large primary blades featuring a 0.036-inch thickness and the second smaller blades having a 0.028-inch thickness.

Each package has just three broadheads and you can get them in either 100 or 125-grain weight. For the 125-grain version, you get 0.040-inch thick primary blades.

They are also available without the smaller bleeder blades, in which case the 100 and 125-grain blades become 80 and 105 grains.

Pros:

  • Features 4 super sharp blades to rip through any animal
  • A 1.125-inch cutting diameter guarantees good blood trails
  • Available in 100 or 125-grain versions
  • Solid construction to offer bone splitting penetration

Cons:

  • A little costly but worth it

10. FlyArchery Traditional Arrow Broadheads

Editor's Rating: 5 out of 5 stars (5 / 5)

FlyArchery Traditional Arrow Broadheads
  • Grain weight: 100 grains
  • Cutting Diameter: 0.6 inch
  • Type of Blade: Fixed

With a 12-pack offered at a very affordable price, here come the second-cheapest broadheads on this list. Unlike the other ones though, this pack features a cutting width of just 0.6 inch.

Designed in a traditional style, these broadheads are not as wide as the others on this list and so, might not produce good blood trails, but they do have their advantages.

The narrow width creates less drag and disturbance during flight, allowing the arrow to fly faster and with the high precision of a field point.

They are easy to sharpen before shooting and are good for all kinds of arrow shafts, including fiberglass, carbon, aluminum, wooden and even bamboo arrows. If you're looking for the best broadheads for hunting small game like squirrels and rabbits, then you've got it.

Pros:

  • They fly like a field point without disturbances or planing
  • Higher speed because of less drag
  • Great price for a pack of 12
  • Perfect for hunting small game like rabbits

Cons:

  • A little too small for hunting large game like deer

Types of Broadheads

In order to better understand broadhead tips, you should know the different types that are available based on their blades. You should also know their advantages and disadvantages because it will help you to choose right.

Following are the 4 major types of broadheads.

#1. Fixed Blade Broadheads

A fixed blade broadhead tip is the most basic type of broadhead you can get and as the name suggests, fixed blade broadheads have their razor-sharp blades fixed permanently. This means that once they get screwed or glued to the arrow, they stay put and do not move in any way.

The advantage of having a fixed blade is that you get an arrow tip that is rigid with razor-sharp blades. So, once they hit an animal, they slice through everything including through bones.

Another advantage is that you can shoot fixed blade broadheads many times before they can finally get damaged.

#2. Removable Blade Broadheads

In a way, removable blades also have their blades fixed in place, but they can get removed to change them when they're damaged or they've gone dull.

#3. Expandable/Mechanical Broadheads

This type of broadhead has its blades folded into the head to offer a more aerodynamic shape and less drag during flight. Once the arrow hits the game though, the blades extend outwards to offer a wider cutting diameter.

The advantage of mechanical broadheads is that the arrows fly straighter and are more accurate. The disadvantage is that you'll hardly use the tips more than once, and that is whether they hit an animal or not. This is because the blades are very thin and bend easily.

#4. Hybrid Broadheads

Hybrid broadheads come from combining fixed blade and mechanical broadheads. They combine the ruggedness of a fixed blade with the wide diameter of an expandable blade.

Hybrid broadheads will usually have 2 or more fixed blades plus larger blades which extend on impact. These expandable blades also hardly last more than one shot.

How to Buy a Broadhead Arrow Tip

How to Buy a Broadhead Arrow Tip

When looking to buy a broadhead tip for hunting, there are certain features you need to look out for and considerations you need to make, so you can make the right choice. These features are as follows.

#1. Number of Blades

The number of blades that a broadhead tip has is important in determining its quality. Firstly, more blades will create a wider hole than just two blades. Secondly, more blades improve the blood trail and are, therefore, better.

A tip with just 2 blades can cut through muscle along the grain, allowing the muscle to close up quickly and you'll lose the blood trail. With 3 or more blades, however, you can always be sure of a good blood trail with at least one blade cutting against the grain.

#2. Cut on Contact vs Chisel Tip

If you are shooting with traditional bows like recurve and longbows, you may want to go with a cut on contact tip. These slice through the meat on contact and requires little energy. They'll, however, usually not be able to damage bones.

Chisel tips, however, have a tip which is actually chisel-like. The aim is to break bones and rupture everything in their path. Chisel tips need a lot of force and are suitable for compound and crossbows.

#3. Size & Penetration

The size or diameter of the blades affects the rate of penetration. The wider the blades, the less penetration you'll get. This does not mean that wide blades are not good because a wider blade cuts through more flesh.

You need to strike a balance between size and penetration for each game you're hunting, so you can get a good penetration with a hole wide enough to leave a good blood trail.

#4. Weight

Weight is another issue you should properly consider to make the best of your hunting experience. Broadheads are available in a range of weights from 85 to 150 grains.

100-grain broadheads are the recommendation for lightweight aluminum and carbon arrow shafts, while you'll need about a 125-grain head for heavier shafts.

#5. Blade material

You need your broadheads made from a tough material which neither bends nor cracks easily. The most popular materials for broadheads are aluminum, stainless steel, and carbon steel. Aluminum is the softest, while carbon steel is the toughest here.

#6. Blade Sharpness

Keeping your blades sharp is important if you want to get consistent clean kills. Blades made from tougher materials will stay sharp longer than others. Sharpen the blades when you can and make replacements if they're damaged.

Conclusion

We have reached the end of this review and the turn is now yours to make a choice. As you have seen, there is a variety of broadhead offers for different hunting needs.

So, whether you're hunting deer, rabbits, or turkey, your choice of a broadhead tip will also depend on whether you are using a longbow, a recurve bow, compound bow, or a crossbow.

For this reason, we have different needs and so, your choice will depend on your preferences.

Whichever broadhead tips you end up choosing though, just remember to have fun with your bow and arrows.

Tom Brady
 

Tom Brady is an online blogger. He loves outdoor activities such as fishing, camping. He write articles about outdoor activities for this blog to share his understanding and experience.